Seminar in Vocal Pedagogy

1IntroTetrazzini
...the foundation of singing is breathing and breath control.
2IntroTetrazzini
"There is only one way to sing correctly, and that is to sing naturally, easily, comfortably.
3DefinitionsTetrazzini
The quality of sound is controlled by the breath.
4IntroReid
There has never been even a suspicion of proof that mastery of singing is in any way dependent upon a correct system of breathing.
5IntroReid
In comparison to the problems of registration and purity of tone quality it is apparent the subject of breathing merited no more than a place of minor importance in Bel Canto instruction.
6IntroReid
Ferrari in A Concise Treatise on Italian Singing advises that "the inspiration should be made at the beginning and at the end of the musical phrase," and that is all he had to say about breathing. Caccini mentions it in a casual way, but neither Tosi nor Mancini discuss it at all.
7IntroVennard
It seems wasteful to spend more than one or two lessons on breathing by itself. The one thing that the teacher must supervise is actual phonation, coordinating the actuator (respiratory system) with the vibrator (vocal cords). The pupil can easily practice singing poor tone without knowing it. He will never practice wrong breathing by himself if he pays attention to what he is doing.
8DefinitionsCaruso
The diaphragm is really like a pair of bellows and serves exactly the same purpose.
9FundamentalsTetrazzini
In learning to sing it is well to think of the lungs as empty sacks, into which the air is dropping like a weight, so that you think first of filling the bottom of your lungs, then the middle part, and so on until no more air can be inhaled.
10DefinitionsReid
The vocal cords only act as a valve on the escaping breath when they are in a position of approcimation. They can only be approximated by the creation of an even balance of tension on both the muscles of inspiration as well as those of expiration.
11DefinitionsReid
Clavicular breathing is a system of inspiration whereby the upper parts of the chest are raised while the diaphragm is drawn in. The effect of this method of breathing is first to interfere with, and then destroy, the effective coordination of the vocal organs.
12ProblemsReid
Clavicular breathing is useless because 1. By raising the chest and lifting the shoulders the muscles of the neck are brought into tension, and 2. Only a partial inspiration can be completed. As the diaphragm is dome-shaped, the act of drawing the diaphragm upward and raising the chst means that only a fraction of its capacity for storing energy is utilized.
13DefinitionsReid
Costal breathing is universally practiced for purposes of daily living. For purposes of singing, it is normal as long as the musical expression does not include dramatic episodes, or phrases to be sung con grande expansione.
14DefinitionsVennard
Many great teachers of singing have agreed with Salvatore Marchesi who did not believe in cosal breathing any more than in clavicular. They felt that the rib muscles should only be used to expand the ribs and keep them in this position making possible the most efficient operation of lower muscels, the true motors of breathing.
15DefinitionsReid
A breath taken with an outward movement of the lower ribs that fills the lungs to their fullest capacity may be described as thoracic, or intercostal breathing.
16DefinitionsReid
The chief advantage of diaphragmatic, or intercostal, breathing is that the vocal cords are free to vibrate wihtou interfering with the glottal movements.
17VocalizationTetrazzini
The feeling of singing against the chest with the weight of air pressing up against it is known as "breath support;" in Italian there is a better word, "apoggio," or breath prop.
18FundamentalsTetrazzini
The immediate pressure of the air should be felt more against the chest.
19DefinitionsVennard
Regarding diaphragmatic-abdominal breathing, probably more breath can be inhaled in this manner than by the sideward epansion of the ribs, though the point is academic since both movements occur at once.
20DefinitionsTetrazzini
The apoggio is the deep breath regulated by the diaphragm.
21FundamentalsReid
The only essential difference between breathing in singing, as against that practiced during ordinary circomstances of living, is that singing demands a constant source of pressure which can only be supplied by a pair of well-filled lungs.
22FundamentalsReid
The effect of intercostal (thoracic) breathing is to create a feeling of expansion around the entire middle part of the body, so that the expansion will include the small of the back and sides, as well as the abdominal wall.
23FundamentalsVennard
It is easy to overemphasize posture. However, the beginner must be reminded that opera stars probalby learned orthodox posture at one time, and the positions they assume on stage, apparently spontaneously, are all such that they do not violate good technic, and they involve compensations to make up for the unorthodoxy.
24PostureTetrazzini
Rigidity of the spinal column will in no way help you in the emission of tone, nor will it increase the breath control.
25FundamentalsReid
Once the student has been made to breathe without raising his chest or shoulders the taking of a breath will automatically cause the diaphragm to do the work for which it was intended by nature.
26ExercisesVennard
It helps to imagine that you are a marionette, hanging from strings, one attached to the top of your head and one attached to the top of your breast bone. This keeps the head erect and lifts the chest, allowing the pelvis just to "hang" in position. The famoust statue, Winged Victory of Samothrace, is considered an inspiration for singers.
27FundamentalsTetrazzini
The physical sensation should be first an effort on the part of the diaphragm to press the air up against the chest box, then the sensation of a perfectly open throat, and, lastly, the sensation that the air is passing freely into the cavities of the head.
28FundamentalsTetrazzini
You must learn to control this flow of air, so that no muscular action of the throat can shut it off.
29FundamentalsReid
The difference between the reserve breath available to a well-produced voice and the gasping distress of the poorly used voice is not due to a voluntarily controlled emission, but is entirely the result of a well-balanced registration.
30FundamentalsTetrazzini
You will notice when you begin to sing, if you watch yourself very carefully, that, first, you will try to inhale too much air; secondly, you will either force it all out at once, making a breathy note, or in trying to control the flow of air by the diaphragm you will suddenly cease to send it forth at all and will be making the sound by pressure from the throat.
31FundamentalsReid
When the vocal mechanism is working efficiently very little is demanded of the breath, because all of the energy used in singing is being directed into constructive channels. Therefore, as the breath is not dissipated and wasted the singer discovers that he has more at his disposal than his needs require.
32FundamentalsCaruso
Open the throat not only in front, but from behind, for the throat is the door through which the voice must pass, and if it is not sufficiently open it is useless to attempt to get out a full, round one.
33FundamentalsReid
In reality very little of the breath taken in is used,k so that on the completion of a phrase the singer should have a quantity of breath left over and to spare. This quantity of breath should be released before each new inspirtation and the muscles allowed a brief moment of relaxation before recommencing the cycle.
34FundamentalsVennard
One sometimes hears the instruction, "Place your hand on your diaphragm." This is a little confusing, because the diaphragm is inside the body, and to touch it one would have to take out his lungs an d put his hand down his throat. What is meant is to place the hand on the abdomen muscles, near the top, at the place where the ribs arch in front, just below the sternum. This region is called the epigastrium, and it is a handy spot to feel the action of the diaphragm.
35ProblemsTetrazzini
A shaky, uncontrolled breath is like a rickety foundation on which nothing can be built, and until that foundation has been developed and strengthened the would-be singer need expect no satisfactory results.
36ProblemsTetrazzini
Do not practice any breathing exercise to such an extent that you make your heart beat fast or feel like stranging.
37ProblemsTetrazzini
Don't try to develop a diaphragm expansion of five inches in two weeks.
38ProblemsReid
Breathing through the nose is inefficient because 1. It is stilted and awkward, 2. It prohibits the swift and quiet inhalation of requisite amounts of air, and 3. It is inclined to lead to a high chest position, which in turn induces throatiness.
39ProblemsChristy
A most pernicious idea often held by students and, unfortunately, mistakenly expressed by many vocal teachers and in some texts is that the body must be relaxed completley in singing. This half-truth applies only to the parts of the body not concerned in the singing actÐthe shoulders, arms, hands and frontal neck muscles.
40ProblemsTetrazzini
Énaturally untrained voices soon break or fail if they are used much unless the singer supplements the natural, God-given vocal gifts with a conscious understanding of how the vocal apparatus should be used.
41ProblemsTetrazzini
Certain young singers take in an enormous breath, stiffening every muscle in order to hold the air, thus depriving their muscles of all elasticity. They will then shut off the throat and let only the smallest fraction of air escape, just enough to make a sound. Too much inbreathing and too violent an effort at inhaling will not help the singer at all.
42ProblemsCaruso
Singers, especially tenors, are very apt to throw the head forward in producing the high notes, and consequently get that throaty, strained voice which is so disagreeable. To avoid this one should try to keep the supply of breath down as far toward the abdomen as possible, thus maintaining the upper passages to the head quite free for the emission of the voice.
43ProblemsCaruso
The "white voice" (voce bianca) is a head voice without deep support and consequently without color; hence its appellation. One can learn to avoid it by practicing with the mouth closed and by taking care to breathe through the nose, which forces the respiration to descend to the abdomen.
44ExercisesCaruso
To practice deep breating effectively it is an excellent plan to breathe through the nose, which aids in keeping the confined breath from escaping too soon.
45ExercisesCaruso
Have the throat well open.
46ExercisesCaruso
To cure oneself of throatiness, attack your notes from the abdomen, the mouth well open, standing in front of a mirror. The force of the respiration will keep the tongue depressed and the throat will remain free.
47ExercisesTetrazzini
In practicing the trill or staccato tones the pressure of the breath must be felt even before the sound is heard. Maintain a perfeclty open throat.
48ExercisesTetrazzini
Feel as if you were pushing the air against your chest.
49ExercisesTetrazzini
To learn "filare la voce," or spinning the voice, slowly snuff in air through the nostrils, inhailing in small puffs. Fill the very bottom and back of your lungs. When you feel you are full up to the neck, retain the air for a few seconds and then very slowly send it out in little puffs again.
50ExercisesCaruso
The lungs, in the first place, should be throughly filled. A tone begun with only half-filled lungs loses half its authority and is very apt to be false in pitch.
51ExercisesChristy
Summary of Rules for Breath Control (p.44); Introductory Breathing and Tonal Production Exercises (pp.44-48)
52PhasesChristy
The key to proper breath control is in inhalatio. It must not be nervous or tense or the remaining phases are futile. Be physical and positive about breathing, never tentative. Inhale deeply, easily and quietly, simultaneously through both nose and mouth.
53PhasesChristy
Amount of breath needed on inhalation is determined not only by the length and rising and falling shape of the phrase but also by the conditioning factors of pitch, dynamics, tempo and tonal color. Inhale positiviely with assurance but just enough breath for the demands of the phrase and a small amount in reserve is the ideal.
54PhasesChristy
Suspension in singing is a moment, perhaps infinitesimal in rapid music, when the inflowing column of breath is stopped in balance, neither moving in nor out, while the throat (vocal cords) remains open preceding the attack.
55PhasesChristy
Resistance starts with suspension when the muscles around the lower ribs and in the diaphragm "hold" back to keep the breath suspended, preventing immediate exhalation.
56PhasesChristy
Phonation, the making of vocal sound, starts with the tonal attack
57VocalizationTetrazzini
From the minute the singer starts to emit a tone the supply of breath must be emitted steadily from the chamber of air in the lungs. It must never be held back once.
58VocalizationTetrazzini
In diminishing the tone the opening of the throat remains the same. Only the quantity of breath given forth is diminished. That is done by the diaphragm muscles.
59PhasesChristy
Recovery is a moment of relaxation and rest, perhaps very slight, following the end of one phrase and preceding the beginning of another. There is a feeling of brief "letting go" of the diaphragm, and of all the msucles around the lower rib line. However, the chest remains eternally high and quiet.

 


 

Bibliography

 

Caruso, Enrico and Luisa Tetrazzini. Caruse and Tetrazzini on the Art of Singing. New York: Dover Publications, 1975.

 

Christy, Van A. Expressing Singing: Guidance, Technical Principles, Exercises, and Basics of Interpretation, Vol. 1. Dubuque, IA: Wm. C. Brown Company Publishers, 1974.

 

Reid, Cornelius L. Bel Canto: Principles and Practice. New York: The Joseph Patelson Music House, 1972.

 

Vennard, William. Singing: the Mechanism and the Technic. 5th ed. New York: Carl Fischer, Inc., 1968.